Both joyticks/buttons for Sega 32X won't configure

[Abqshark]

I'm trying to get my player 2 joystick to work with Sega 32X games and I think it us just writing over joystick 1, when I got into Retroarch and set up the binds. I'm using a Xin Mo encoder, and RetroArch. Is there some setting I'm missing that can tell RetroArch that they are 2 different joysticks and buttons? Here's a screenshot of what I'm working with in RetroArch > Setting > Input Options. I had to put the screenshot as an attachment to this post. Should I turn off Autoconfig and go edit the config files with Notepad ++? The Bind Mode only gives me options for RetroPad, or RetroKeyboard.